High guna score but a dosha in the match: talk to an astrologer about which one counts
A good total can hide a nadi or bhakoot dosha, and many astrologers read the dosha first and the number second.
On an iPhone, log in on kismo.app in your browser.
- 18,000+ verified astrologers
- From ₹15 a minute
- 5 free minutes on your first session
- Chat or call, in 16+ languages
- Updated
Your astrologer
Online · chat
We have 27 gunas, which everyone says is great, but the report also shows nadi dosha. Which one should we believe?
Both lines are true, and they answer different questions. Please send both birth dates, times and places. I check your Moon signs, stars and quarters to see if a nadi exception applies.
Short answer
A high guna score with nadi or bhakoot dosha is common: more than half of all matches at 18 or more have one of the two at zero. Drik Panchang reads even 28 as inauspicious when nadi fails 2, and Muhurta Chintamani judges both doshas in their own verses, with exceptions 1. On Kismo, verified Vedic astrologers check the dosha, its exceptions and both charts by chat or call, online from anywhere.
What are the key facts about low guna score?
| Answer | |
|---|---|
| The situation | A total of 18 to 28 of 36 with nadi or bhakoot at zero, searched as high guna but nadi dosha or 28 gun milan with dosha |
| How often | 56.0% of matches scoring 18 or more have nadi or bhakoot at zero (calculated) |
| Highest possible score | 28 with nadi at zero, 28 with bhakoot at zero, 21 with both (calculated) |
| What an astrologer checks | Which dosha it is, its exception, regional practice, then both 7th houses and manglik status |
| What can soften it | The bhakoot lord rule and the three nadi cases in Muhurta Chintamani 1 |
| Session on Kismo | From ₹15 a minute, 5 free minutes in the first session, online from anywhere in India and abroad |
What does an astrologer check when a high guna score comes with a dosha?
- Which dosha it is. Muhurta Chintamani reads nadi in verse 34 and bhakoot in verse 31, each on its own terms 1, so the total does not settle either.
- For nadi, the three exception cases: a shared Moon sign with different stars, or a shared star in a different sign or quarter 1.
- For bhakoot, the distance and the lords. Moon signs that share a lord or have friendly lords lift the dosha in the same text 1.
- Regional practice. The Hindi commentary on Muhurta Chintamani says the side nadis' dosha is not applied south of the Godavari 1.
- Manglik status in both charts. Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra reads Mars in certain houses separately from the guna table 5, so a high total says nothing about it.
- Both 7th houses and the running dashas, read before any advice on the match.
What changes the answer when the score is high but a dosha shows?
- Nadi or bhakoot. Drik Panchang treats a failed nadi as more serious, reading 28 as inauspicious, while a failed bhakoot only caps the match below excellent 2.
- Whether an exception applies. In the calculation on this page, about 47% of 18-plus matches with a dosha meet one of the Muhurta Chintamani exceptions.
- Which nadi is shared. Muhurta Chintamani treats a shared middle nadi as the most serious case 1.
- Where the family comes from. A South Indian reading may set the side nadis aside 1 or weigh rajju and other poruthams instead 3.
How often does a high guna score come with nadi or bhakoot dosha?
A high guna score comes with nadi or bhakoot dosha in about one match in two at 18 or more. Calculated over all 11,664 Moon-quarter pairs with the standard tables.
| Calculated fact | Result |
|---|---|
| 18-plus matches with nadi at zero | 17.8% |
| 18-plus matches with bhakoot at zero | 41.2% |
| 25-plus matches with nadi at zero | 12.1% |
| 25-plus matches with bhakoot at zero | 20.7% |
| All pairs scoring 25 or more with nadi at zero | 3.8% |
| Highest total with nadi at zero | 28 |
| Highest total with nadi and bhakoot both at zero | 21 |
The highest total with nadi at zero matches Drik Panchang's own example: 28 is the top a nadi-failed match can reach, and the tutorial reads it as inauspicious 2.
Does a dosha outweigh a high guna score in the classical texts?
Muhurta Chintamani never adds the doshas into a single verdict with the total. Verse 21 gives the 36 points, while verses 31 to 37 judge bhakoot and nadi as separate rules with their own exceptions 1.
The commentary records how much traditions differ on nadi. Some regions count four or five nadis, and one view says adi nadi falls on the groom, antya on the bride and madhya on both 1. B. V. Raman links the three nadis to vata, pitta and kapha 4.
Bhakoot has older disagreements still. Prasna Marga records that Sarvasiddhi rejects the 2nd to 6th signs from the girl's, while Brihaspati allows a 6-8 pair when the signs share a lord or the lords are friends 3.
| Rule | What it says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Muhurta Chintamani 6.34 | Same nadi is a dosha; a shared middle nadi most serious | 1 |
| Muhurta Chintamani 6.37 | Three nakshatra and sign cases lift nadi dosha | 1 |
| Commentary on 6.34 | Side nadis' dosha not applied south of the Godavari | 1 |
| Prasna Marga 21.5-10 | Authorities disagree on which bhakoot distances to reject | 3 |
| Drik Panchang tutorial | Nadi failed: 28 inauspicious; bhakoot failed: never excellent | 2 |
How often is the dosha in a high-scoring match cancelled?
The dosha in a high-scoring match meets a Muhurta Chintamani exception in roughly half of cases, more often for bhakoot than for nadi 1.
| Calculated fact, matches scoring 18 or more | Share |
|---|---|
| With a dosha, where every dosha present meets an exception | 47.0% |
| With bhakoot at zero, Moon-sign lords the same or friends | 55.8% |
| With nadi at zero, meeting a nadi exception | 30.9% |
| With nadi at zero, both Moons in the same sign | 35.2% |
| Bhakoot at zero from a 5-9 distance | 45.1% |
| Bhakoot at zero from a 2-12 distance | 30.6% |
| Bhakoot at zero from a 6-8 distance | 24.3% |
High-scoring nadi doshas often come from couples sharing a Moon sign, which keeps bhakoot and graha maitri full. That is also the first nadi exception the text names 1.
Do North and South Indian astrologers read a nadi dosha in a high score the same way?
North and South Indian astrologers often read a nadi dosha differently. North Indian practice usually treats it as serious whatever the total, while the commentary on Muhurta Chintamani exempts the side nadis south of the Godavari 1.
| Practice | How a high score with nadi dosha is read | Source |
|---|---|---|
| North Indian ashtakoot | Nadi given top priority; 28 with nadi failed read as inauspicious | 2 |
| Muhurta Chintamani commentary, south of the Godavari | Only a shared middle nadi counted | 1 |
| B. V. Raman, South Indian kutas | Nadi can be set aside when rasi and rajju agree and one planet rules both signs | 4 |
| Kerala, Prasna Marga | Items judged one by one, no total to outweigh | 3 |
What do people get wrong about this?
Belief: A score above 25 means there can be no dosha.
A match can score up to 28 with nadi at zero, and 12.1% of 25-plus matches have it in the calculation on this page. Drik Panchang reads such a 28 as inauspicious 2.
Belief: Nadi dosha is read the same everywhere in India.
The commentary on Muhurta Chintamani says the side nadis' dosha is not applied south of the Godavari, and records regions counting four or five nadis 1.
Before you pay anyone
How do you know an astrologer is genuine?
- Every Kismo astrologer passes four steps: qualification review, panel interview, live audits of real sessions, 30-day probation.
- Nobody can guarantee an outcome. Treat any promise of a fixed result as a red flag.
- Never pay for an expensive puja or ritual under pressure. Get a second opinion first.
- On Kismo you only pay for the minutes you use; misconduct, pressure or a request for money outside the app is handled by a person.
Which astrologers can I talk to about low guna score?
How does a consultation on Kismo work?
- Log in on kismo.app or get the app from Google Play.
- Pick an astrologer who speaks your language and works with your question.
- Share your date, time and place of birth.
- Ask by chat or call. The first session carries 5 free minutes, then each minute is billed from your wallet.
Questions worth asking in the session
- Is the dosha in our match nadi, bhakoot or both?
- Do our Moon signs, stars or quarters meet a nadi exception?
- Do our Moon-sign lords share a lord or count as friends?
- Which nadi do we share, and which tradition do you follow for it?
- Is either of us manglik, separately from the guna score?
What should I know before booking a session about low guna score?
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What does a session cost? | Each astrologer sets one rate for chat and call, from ₹15 a minute. A 10-minute session at ₹15 a minute costs ₹150 (October 2026). |
| Is the first session free? | 5 free minutes on the first session, no card. |
| Chat or call? | Both. You choose when you start the session. |
| Do I need an exact birth time? | It helps. Without one an astrologer can still read your Moon sign and planets by sign, or work out the time with you. |
| Is my chat private? | Your chat is not shown to other clients. How Kismo handles your data is set out in its privacy policy at kismo.app/privacy. |
| What if I am not happy? | There is no refund for a reading you did not like. Misconduct, pressure or a request for money outside Kismo is handled by a person. |
| Where does it work? | Online, from anywhere in India and abroad. People use Kismo from 80+ countries. |
What else do people ask an astrologer about?
How does Kismo compare with other apps?
Questions people ask
We have 28 gunas but nadi dosha. Should we be worried?
A 28 with nadi dosha is a match to read carefully, not a reason for panic. Drik Panchang reads it as inauspicious, while Muhurta Chintamani lifts nadi dosha when the Moons share a sign with different stars, or share a star in a different sign or quarter. An astrologer checks which case is yours.
Can a high guna score cancel nadi dosha?
No, a high guna score does not cancel nadi dosha by itself. The classical exceptions depend on the two Moons' signs, stars and quarters, not on the total. In fact many high-scoring nadi doshas come from couples sharing a Moon sign, which is one of the named exceptions, so the check is worth making.
Is bhakoot dosha less serious than nadi dosha?
Many astrologers treat bhakoot dosha as less serious than nadi dosha. Drik Panchang caps a match with bhakoot failed below excellent, but reads a nadi-failed 28 as inauspicious. Muhurta Chintamani also says bhakoot exceptions only count when nadi is clean.
Can a Kismo astrologer check whether our dosha is cancelled?
Yes, a verified Vedic astrologer on Kismo can check your Moon signs, stars and quarters against the exceptions, by chat or call. Rates start at ₹15 a minute, the first session has 5 free minutes, and only the minutes you use are charged from your wallet.
We were told to do nadi dosha shanti even with 27 gunas. Is that needed?
Nobody can say a shanti is needed or promise what it does. The commentary on Muhurta Chintamani names Mahamrityunjaya japa and the gift of a gold nadi as traditional remedies. Check first whether an exception lifts the dosha, and get a second opinion before paying for any ritual. On Kismo, pressure to pay is misconduct that a person handles.
Does a high guna score also mean we are not manglik?
No, the guna score and manglik dosha are separate checks. The 36 points compare only the two Moons, while manglik dosha looks at the house of Mars in each chart. A match can score 30 and still have one partner manglik, so ask for both checks.
Talk to an astrologer about low guna score
Kismo is an app where you talk to verified Vedic astrologers by chat or call, in 16 languages.
On an iPhone, log in on kismo.app in your browser.
Where do these facts come from?
- Muhurta Chintamani of Daivagya Shri Ramacharya with Hindi commentary by Pt. Mahidhara Sharma, ch. 6 (Vivaha Prakarana), vv. 21, 31-34, 37, Khemraj Shri Krishna Das Prakashan, Mumbai, via Internet Archive. Accessed .
- Kundali Matching (Ashta-Kuta) tutorial, Drik Panchang. Accessed .
- Prasna Marga, Part 2, chapter 21: marriage compatibility, stanzas 4-10 (tr. B. V. Raman), Internet Archive. Accessed .
- Muhurtha or Electional Astrology, nadi kuta, pp. 91-93 (B. V. Raman, 1948), Internet Archive (Digital Library of India). Accessed .
- Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, chapter 80, verse 47, Enjoy Learning Sanskrit. Accessed .
