Manglik dosha second opinion: am I really manglik, and who can check again?
Two astrologers can read the same chart and disagree about manglik dosha, because the house lists, reference points and cancellation rules they use are not the same.
On an iPhone, log in on kismo.app in your browser.
- 18,000+ verified astrologers
- From ₹15 a minute
- 5 free minutes on your first session
- Chat or call, in 16+ languages
- Updated
Your astrologer
Online · chat
Our pandit says my daughter is high manglik and rejected a good proposal. An app says she isn't manglik at all. Can you check her chart again?
Yes. Please send her birth date, exact time and place, and the pandit's report if you have it. I'll first see which house list and reference point each one used.
Short answer
A second opinion on manglik dosha checks whether Mars really sits in a manglik house, by which house list and from which reference point, whether your birth time is right, and whether a cancellation was missed. Published rules disagree on most charts, so a different verdict is common, not a sign of error. On Kismo, after a session you are suggested up to three other astrologers, online from anywhere.
What are the key facts about manglik dosha?
| Answer | |
|---|---|
| When people ask for one | Two reports disagree, a match was rejected, or a costly puja was suggested |
| Why verdicts differ | House lists, reference points, cancellation rules and birth time |
| How often rules disagree | On about 7 charts in 10, across five published rules (calculated) |
| What to bring | Date, exact time and place of birth, the first astrologer's report, the partner's details |
| Second opinion on Kismo | Up to three other astrologers suggested after a session |
| Session on Kismo | From ₹15 a minute, 5 free minutes in the first session, online from anywhere in India and abroad |
What does an astrologer re-check in a manglik dosha second opinion?
- The birth time and place. An astrologer in a 2023 Jammu study warned that wrong birth details make any matching result wrong 1.
- The house list. BPHS 80.47 names five houses, the Kerala stanza a different five, and the Tamil Lexicon only three 234.
- The reference point. Raman counts Mars from the ascendant, the Moon and Venus, and grades it weakest to strongest in that order 3.
- The cancellations. BPHS 80.47 excludes Mars seen or joined by a benefic, and the Kerala list adds sign exceptions 23.
- The partner's chart and the full match. Raman's own advice is that no horoscope should be rejected until it has been examined from all angles 3.
What decides whether a second opinion on manglik dosha comes out differently?
- How the first verdict was reached. A software report with no named rule is easier to overturn than a reading that names the house, sign and cancellation.
- Whether the birth time was rounded. Times written as 6 or 6:30 instead of 6:17 can move the ascendant and with it the house of Mars.
- The tradition of each astrologer. A North Indian astrologer may leave out the 2nd house that a South Indian astrologer counts 1.
- Whether a match was already rejected. The second reading then needs both charts, not only the one called manglik.
How often do manglik rules disagree on the same chart?
Five published manglik rules disagree on about 71.5% of charts. The shares were calculated from public astronomical data with the open-source astronomia library: 10,000 random charts for Delhi, born 1960 to 2005, Lahiri ayanamsa, whole-sign houses.
| Rule applied to the same 10,000 charts | Charts called manglik |
|---|---|
| BPHS 80.47: 1, 4, 7, 8, 12 from the ascendant | 42.0% |
| Kerala stanza: 2, 4, 7, 8, 12 from the ascendant | 42.2% |
| Common six houses from the ascendant | 50.8% |
| Tamil Lexicon: 1, 7, 8 from the ascendant | 25.5% |
| Six houses from the ascendant, Moon or Venus | 88.4% |
| All five rules agree: manglik | 16.9% |
| All five rules agree: not manglik | 11.6% |
| The rules disagree | 71.5% |
Birth time adds to this. Casting the same charts for the time rounded to the nearest hour changed the six-house verdict for 6.3% of them.
Why can two astrologers read the same chart and disagree about manglik dosha?
Two astrologers can disagree about manglik dosha because the source texts themselves disagree. BPHS 80.47 counts Mars in the 1st, 4th, 7th, 8th and 12th houses 2. The Kerala stanza that Raman quotes swaps the 1st for the 2nd 3.
Raman himself thought the dosha was given too much weight. He wrote that he had found it named only in the Kerala shastra, and that it had kept many otherwise eligible marriages from happening 3. He listed sign exceptions he said most astrologers did not know 3.
Raman also told readers to check their own conclusions. His summary advises comparing your inferences with experienced astrologers before trusting them 3. A second opinion follows the same idea.
| Source | Houses counted | Reference points | Exceptions it gives |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra 80.47 2 | 1, 4, 7, 8, 12 | Not stated in the verse | Benefic aspect or conjunction on Mars |
| Kerala stanza, quoted by B. V. Raman 3 | 2, 4, 7, 8, 12 | Lagna, Moon, Venus | Five house and sign pairs; Leo, Aquarius; Mars with Jupiter or the Moon |
| Tamil Lexicon, chevvai dosham 4 | 1, 7, 8 | Ascendant | None listed |
| North Indian practice, per a 2023 study 1 | 1, 4, 7, 8, 12 | Ascendant, sometimes the Moon too | Varies by astrologer |
What should I collect before getting a second opinion on manglik dosha?
A second opinion on manglik dosha is quicker and cheaper when you bring the first reading's details with you.
| Bring this | Why it helps |
|---|---|
| Birth time from a certificate or hospital record | A rounded time can change the house of Mars |
| The first report or the pandit's notes | Shows which house list and reference point were used |
| The house and sign of Mars, if written down | Lets the second astrologer check cancellations directly |
| The partner's full birth details | The both-charts rule and the full match need them |
| Any price quoted for a ritual | A second astrologer who is not selling it can say if it is needed |
What do people get wrong about this?
Belief: If two astrologers disagree about manglik dosha, one of them made a mistake.
Both can be right by their own rules. The house lists in BPHS 80.47, the Kerala stanza and the Tamil Lexicon differ, so the same Mars can count for one and not another 234.
Belief: A match rejected for manglik dosha should never be checked again.
Astrologers quoted in the 2023 Jammu study said many matches are rejected for a manglik label or a low guna score without a deeper look at both charts 1.
Before you pay anyone
How do you know an astrologer is genuine?
- Every Kismo astrologer passes four steps: qualification review, panel interview, live audits of real sessions, 30-day probation.
- Nobody can guarantee an outcome. Treat any promise of a fixed result as a red flag.
- Never pay for an expensive puja or ritual under pressure. Get a second opinion first.
- On Kismo you only pay for the minutes you use; misconduct, pressure or a request for money outside the app is handled by a person.
Which astrologers can I talk to about manglik dosha?
How does a consultation on Kismo work?
- Log in on kismo.app or get the app from Google Play.
- Pick an astrologer who speaks your language and works with your question.
- Share your date, time and place of birth.
- Ask by chat or call. The first session carries 5 free minutes, then each minute is billed from your wallet.
Questions worth asking in the session
- Which house list and reference point did you use?
- Is my birth time exact enough for the house of Mars to be sure?
- Which cancellation rules did you check, and which apply?
- Would you call me manglik under the Kerala list and under BPHS?
- What does the full match show beyond Mars?
What should I know before booking a session about manglik dosha?
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What does a session cost? | Each astrologer sets one rate for chat and call, from ₹15 a minute. A 10-minute session at ₹15 a minute costs ₹150 (October 2026). |
| Is the first session free? | 5 free minutes on the first session, no card. |
| Chat or call? | Both. You choose when you start the session. |
| Do I need an exact birth time? | It helps. Without one an astrologer can still read your Moon sign and planets by sign, or work out the time with you. |
| Is my chat private? | Your chat is not shown to other clients. How Kismo handles your data is set out in its privacy policy at kismo.app/privacy. |
| What if I am not happy? | There is no refund for a reading you did not like. Misconduct, pressure or a request for money outside Kismo is handled by a person. |
| Where does it work? | Online, from anywhere in India and abroad. People use Kismo from 80+ countries. |
What else do people ask an astrologer about?
How does Kismo compare with other apps?
Questions people ask
Am I really manglik? Two astrologers told me different things.
You may be manglik by one rule and not by another, which is why the two answers differ. Ask each astrologer which houses they count, from which point, and which cancellations they checked. Five published rules disagree on most charts, so the method matters more than the verdict.
How do I check if I am manglik or not by date of birth?
You need your date, exact time and place of birth, not the date alone, because the time sets the house of Mars. A free kundli tool shows where Mars sits. Then check it against a named house list, and ask an astrologer whether a cancellation applies to your chart.
Is manglik dosha real, or do astrologers exaggerate it?
Manglik dosha is a real rule in Vedic astrology texts, but even B. V. Raman, a well-known 20th-century astrologer, wrote that it gets more weight than it deserves. Whether it affects a marriage is a matter of belief. What a second opinion can check is whether the rule was applied correctly.
Our match was rejected because of manglik dosha. Is it worth asking another astrologer?
Yes, asking another astrologer is worth it when a match was rejected on the manglik label alone. Bring both charts and the first astrologer's reasoning. Cancellations are often missed, and a full reading may change the view. The final choice still belongs to the two families and the couple.
Why does one kundli app say manglik and another say not manglik?
Kundli apps use different house lists, reference points and cancellation rules, and some count the Moon and Venus while others do not. A few may also use a slightly different ayanamsa or birth place. Compare the house and sign of Mars in both, then ask which rule each app applied.
Can I ask a different astrologer about the same manglik chart on Kismo?
On Kismo, after a session you are suggested up to three other astrologers, so you can ask a second one about the same chart. Kismo is an app where you talk to verified Vedic astrologers by chat or call, in 16 languages. Each astrologer charges their own rate, from ₹15 a minute.
What are the red flags when an astrologer says I am high manglik?
The red flags are fear, a deadline, a promise that a paid ritual removes the dosha, and refusing to name the house or rule. An honest astrologer explains the placement and the cancellations without selling anything. Every Kismo astrologer passes a qualification review, a panel interview, live audits of real sessions and a 30-day probation.
Talk to an astrologer about manglik dosha
Kismo is an app where you talk to verified Vedic astrologers by chat or call, in 16 languages.
On an iPhone, log in on kismo.app in your browser.
Where do these facts come from?
- Significance of Horoscope Matching in Marriages among the Hindu Dogras of Jammu District: A Sociological Analysis of Manglik Dosha (Abhinandan), The Eastern Anthropologist 76:3 (2023), Serials Publications. Accessed .
- Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, chapter 80, verse 47, Enjoy Learning Sanskrit. Accessed .
- Muhurtha or Electional Astrology (B. V. Raman, 1948), pp. 98-100 and 187, Internet Archive (Digital Library of India). Accessed .
- Tamil Lexicon (University of Madras), entry செவ்வாய்தோஷம், p. 1614, Digital Dictionaries of South Asia, University of Chicago. Accessed .
