A second opinion on pitra dosh: ask another astrologer which rule and which birth time were used
Two astrologers can disagree on pitra dosh in the same chart, because they use different rule lists and the houses depend on the exact birth time.
On an iPhone, log in on kismo.app in your browser.
- 18,000+ verified astrologers
- From ₹15 a minute
- 5 free minutes on your first session
- Chat or call, in 16+ languages
- Updated
Your astrologer
Online · chat
One astrologer says I have strong pitra dosh, another says I have none. My birth time is from memory, around 7 in the morning. Who is right?
Both may be reading correctly from different rules. Tell me the rule each one used. Then I will check the signs that do not depend on your time, and test your birth time against a few life events.
Short answer
A second opinion on pitra dosh is worth getting, because the answer depends on which rule list is used and on the birth time. By one calculation, an hour's error in birth time changes the result on a common list for 27.1% of charts 1. On Kismo, after a session you are suggested up to three other astrologers for a second opinion, online from anywhere.
What are the key facts about pitra dosh?
| Answer | |
|---|---|
| Why readings differ | Rule lists range from one test to eight; the classical verses add their own conditions 25 |
| Birth time effect | Status on an eight-test list changes for 14.2% of charts with a 30-minute error, 27.1% with an hour (calculated) 1 |
| What does not move | The Sun with Rahu or Ketu is set by signs, so a one-hour error never changed it in the sample 1 |
| Father's house | The 9th in Phaladeepika, the 10th in Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra 34 |
| What to bring | Your birth details, how sure you are of the time, and the first astrologer's exact words |
| Session on Kismo | From ₹15 a minute, 5 free minutes in the first session, online from anywhere in India and abroad |
What makes two pitra dosh readings of the same chart disagree?
- The rule list. The Sun with Rahu alone flags 8.2% of charts; an eight-test list flags 54.5% 1.
- The birth time. Tests that use houses, such as a node in the 9th, change with the ascendant; tests that use only signs do not 1.
- The father's house. One astrologer may read the 9th house, another the 10th 34.
- Whether the classical conditions are applied. Most father's curse verses need the 5th house and ascendant afflicted, and some astrologers skip that step 5.
How much does birth time change a pitra dosh reading?
Birth time changes a pitra dosh reading for about 1 chart in 4 when the time is off by an hour. This was calculated from public astronomical data with the open-source astronomia library: 20,000 random births in Delhi, each moved earlier and later 1.
| Rule list | Error in birth time | Charts whose result changes |
|---|---|---|
| Eight tests (Outlook list) | 30 minutes either way | 14.2% |
| Eight tests (Outlook list) | 1 hour either way | 27.1% |
| Four core tests (Sun with a node, node in the 9th, 9th lord with a node) | 1 hour either way | 34.5% |
| Sun with Rahu only | 1 hour either way | 0.0% |
The four core tests flag 39.7% of charts, between the one-test and eight-test figures 1. So the same chart can be called clear, mild or strong depending only on the list.
Why do classical texts give astrologers room to disagree about pitra dosh?
The classical texts disagree on where the father sits in a chart. Phaladeepika lists pitru among the names of the 9th house 3, while Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra 11.11 reads the father from the 10th 4.
Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra also asks for more than a placement. Its father's curse verses mostly add that the 5th house and ascendant are afflicted, and verse 29 is one of the few that sets no extra condition 5. An astrologer who skips those conditions will find the dosha far more often.
Modern lists then add tests the old texts do not have. The 2024 Outlook list counts the Sun or Jupiter with a node as partial, and Rahu in the ascendant with its lord in the 6th, 8th or 12th 2.
Which pitra dosh rule list did my astrologer use?
Astrologers use at least four kinds of pitra dosh rule list, and each flags a different share of charts. Ask which one your reading came from.
| Rule list | What it counts | Charts flagged | Needs birth time? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sun with Rahu | The Sun and Rahu in one sign | 8.2% 1 | No |
| Core four | Sun with a node, a node in the 9th, 9th lord with a node | 39.7% 1 | Yes |
| Outlook eight-test list 2 | The core four plus Jupiter, Saturn and ascendant tests | 54.5% 1 | Yes |
| BPHS 83.20-30 5 | The Sun, 9th and 5th lords, with the 5th and ascendant afflicted | Rare; verse 27 in full 2 of 20,000 1 | Yes |
What do people get wrong about this?
Belief: If two astrologers disagree, one of them must be wrong.
Both can be reading correctly from different lists: one test flags 8.2% of charts, eight tests flag 54.5% 1.
Belief: A second opinion is only needed if you plan to pay for a puja.
A birth time an hour off changes the result for 27.1% of charts on a common list 1, so checking the time helps any reading.
Before you pay anyone
How do you know an astrologer is genuine?
- Every Kismo astrologer passes four steps: qualification review, panel interview, live audits of real sessions, 30-day probation.
- Nobody can guarantee an outcome. Treat any promise of a fixed result as a red flag.
- Never pay for an expensive puja or ritual under pressure. Get a second opinion first.
- On Kismo you only pay for the minutes you use; misconduct, pressure or a request for money outside the app is handled by a person.
Which astrologers can I talk to about pitra dosh?
How does a consultation on Kismo work?
- Log in on kismo.app or get the app from Google Play.
- Pick an astrologer who speaks your language and works with your question.
- Share your date, time and place of birth.
- Ask by chat or call. The first session carries 5 free minutes, then each minute is billed from your wallet.
Questions worth asking in the session
- Which rule list did you use, and which test did my chart meet?
- Does the result depend on my birth time, or only on signs?
- Do you read my father from the 9th house or the 10th?
- Are the classical conditions on the 5th house and ascendant met?
- Can you check my birth time against events in my life?
What should I know before booking a session about pitra dosh?
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| What does a session cost? | Each astrologer sets one rate for chat and call, from ₹15 a minute. A 10-minute session at ₹15 a minute costs ₹150 (October 2026). |
| Is the first session free? | 5 free minutes on the first session, no card. |
| Chat or call? | Both. You choose when you start the session. |
| Do I need an exact birth time? | It helps. Without one an astrologer can still read your Moon sign and planets by sign, or work out the time with you. |
| Is my chat private? | Your chat is not shown to other clients. How Kismo handles your data is set out in its privacy policy at kismo.app/privacy. |
| What if I am not happy? | There is no refund for a reading you did not like. Misconduct, pressure or a request for money outside Kismo is handled by a person. |
| Where does it work? | Online, from anywhere in India and abroad. People use Kismo from 80+ countries. |
What else do people ask an astrologer about?
How does Kismo compare with other apps?
Questions people ask
One astrologer found pitra dosh in my kundli and another did not. How can both be true?
Two astrologers usually differ on pitra dosh because they use different rule lists or a different birth time. One test can flag 8% of charts and an eight-test list more than half. Ask each one which test your chart met; often both are reading correctly from their own rule.
Does my exact birth time matter for pitra dosh?
Yes for most tests, because a node in the 9th house or the 9th lord depends on the ascendant, which moves with time. An hour's error changed the result for about 1 chart in 4 in a 20,000-chart calculation. The Sun with Rahu does not depend on the time at all.
My birth time is approximate. Can an astrologer still check pitra dosh?
Yes, an astrologer can check the signs that need no birth time, such as the Sun with Rahu or Ketu. For house-based tests they may try birth time rectification from dated life events like marriage, a move or a parent's death, which takes longer and stays less certain.
What should I ask the second astrologer about pitra dosh?
Ask which test your chart meets, whether it depends on your birth time, and which house they read for your father. Then ask whether the 5th house and ascendant show the affliction the classical verses need. Bring the first astrologer's exact words so the second can compare.
Is my pitra dosh report from an app reliable?
An app report is reliable only for the rule its maker chose, and it rarely says which one. Many reports use a long list that flags more than half of all charts. Read it as a list of placements to discuss, then ask a person which ones matter in your full chart.
After a pitra dosh reading on Kismo, how do I find another astrologer to compare?
After a session on Kismo you are suggested up to three other astrologers for a second opinion. Kismo is an app where you talk to verified Vedic astrologers by chat or call, in 16 languages. Each sets one rate, from ₹15 a minute, and only minutes used are charged.
Can I get a refund if I disagree with a pitra dosh reading on Kismo?
No, Kismo gives no refund for a reading you did not like. Misconduct is different: no reply after accepting, pressure, or asking for money outside the app is handled by a person. If you simply disagree, a second astrologer is the better step.
The first astrologer said I must book a puja today. Is that a red flag?
Yes, a same-day deadline for a puja is a warning sign. Pitra dosh is read from a birth chart that does not change, so nothing is lost by waiting for a second opinion. The rites for ancestors that the texts name can be done by the family at almost no cost.
Talk to an astrologer about pitra dosh
Kismo is an app where you talk to verified Vedic astrologers by chat or call, in 16 languages.
On an iPhone, log in on kismo.app in your browser.
Where do these facts come from?
- Calculated from public astronomical data with the open-source astronomia library (20,000 random charts, each moved 30 and 60 minutes; script seo-kit/calc/pitra-dosh.mts), astronomia (open-source library). Accessed .
- Pitra Dosha in Astrology: Its Impact on Human Life and Effective Remedies to Remove It (Dr. Sohini Sastri, 11 September 2024), Outlook India. Accessed .
- Phaladeepika by Mantreswara, chapter 1, sloka 14: names of the 9th house (tr. V. Subrahmanya Sastri, 1950), Wisdom Library. Accessed .
- Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, chapter 11, verse 11: the 10th house, Enjoy Learning Sanskrit. Accessed .
- Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, chapter 83, verses 20-30, Enjoy Learning Sanskrit. Accessed .
